Updated by
Founded in 2019, UOLLB is a global legal education platform providing high-quality study resources, exam preparation materials and careers advice for law students. We make complex legal concepts simple and clear, helping you build knowledge, develop confidence and achieve your academic goals.
For lawyers working towards partnership or a senior position, few things are more frustrating than watching a law firm recruit someone externally to fill a role they have spent years working towards. An associate may have built strong client relationships, consistently delivered high-quality work and demonstrated commitment to the firm, only to discover that a senior position has been offered to a lateral hire from a competing practice.
It raises an obvious question: why do law firms look outside when they already have talented lawyers within their own ranks?
There are several reasons, ranging from commercial considerations and client relationships to internal politics and the perceived value of external experience. Understanding these reasons can help you decide whether to remain with your current firm or take your experience elsewhere.
Why law firms prefer lateral hires
1. External candidates bring an established client following
For many law firms, particularly those competing for high-value commercial work, an incoming lawyer's client relationships can be just as important as their legal expertise. A senior associate or partner joining from another firm may bring established relationships, referral networks and, in some cases, a portable client following.
Promoting an existing associate may strengthen the firm's internal team, but recruiting an experienced partner from a competitor could generate additional revenue almost immediately. From a commercial perspective, the latter may be a more attractive proposition.
This is particularly relevant at partnership level, where law firms are not simply appointing experienced lawyers. They are investing in individuals who can contribute to the firm's profitability, attract new instructions and develop existing client relationships.
2. External candidates fill experience gaps
An internal candidate may be an excellent lawyer but lack experience in a particular practice area, industry or type of transaction. For example, a firm looking to expand its private equity practice may prefer to recruit a partner who has spent several years advising private equity funds rather than promote an existing corporate associate who has limited exposure to that market.
External recruitment allows law firms to acquire specialist expertise without waiting for an existing employee to develop it.
This is especially important when firms are expanding into new markets, responding to changes in client demand or trying to compete with established practices at rival firms.
3. Law firms want to compete with rival practices
The legal profession is highly competitive. Law firms regularly compete for clients, revenue, rankings and experienced legal talent. Recruiting a recognised partner or team from another firm can strengthen a practice and potentially improve its market position.
A lateral hire may also bring knowledge of how competitors operate, their pricing strategies, client expectations and internal processes. This experience can be commercially valuable to a firm looking to improve its own offering.
In some circumstances, recruiting externally is also a way of preventing a competitor from benefiting from the experience and relationships of a highly regarded lawyer.
4. Internal promotion can create organisational difficulties
Promoting an existing employee into a senior position is not always straightforward. A lawyer who becomes a partner may suddenly find themselves managing former colleagues, supervising people with whom they previously worked at the same level and making decisions that affect established workplace relationships.
There may also be several internal candidates competing for the same position. Promoting one associate over another can create resentment, particularly where both have similar experience and believe they deserve the opportunity.
An external appointment can avoid some of these internal difficulties. A lateral hire arrives with a different professional background and is less directly connected to existing workplace relationships.
5. Firms may underestimate their own talent
One of the less comfortable explanations is that some law firms place greater value on experience gained elsewhere than on the development of their existing employees.
An associate who has worked at the same firm for eight years may understand its clients, systems and culture better than almost anyone. However, management may view a candidate from a prestigious competitor as having greater commercial value or a stronger professional reputation.
This can create a perception that lawyers need to leave their firm to receive recognition for their abilities. It can also become a self-fulfilling problem: talented associates leave to secure promotions elsewhere, forcing the original firm to recruit externally to replace them.
6. External recruitment can be quicker
Developing an internal candidate takes time. An associate may need further experience, client exposure, management responsibilities and business development opportunities before becoming ready for a senior position.
An external candidate who already possesses these qualities can potentially step into the role immediately.
For firms facing pressure to expand a department, replace a departing partner or respond to increasing client demand, recruiting someone with an established track record may appear to be the more practical option.
What can employees do?
Finding out why law firms recruit externally is one thing. Deciding what to do when it happens is another.
For lawyers who have spent years developing their careers within one organisation, there are two obvious options: stay and continue working towards promotion, or move to another firm where better opportunities may be available.
Neither decision is automatically right. The important thing is to understand what your current firm can realistically offer.
Should you stay or jump ship?
Stay if there is a genuine opportunity for progression
Not every external appointment means that internal promotion is impossible. There may be legitimate reasons why a particular position required someone with different experience or a specialist skill set.
If the firm recognises your potential, provides meaningful development opportunities and has a clear progression structure, staying may be the better decision.
However, lawyers should avoid relying on vague assurances about future promotions. If management says that partnership or promotion is achievable in two or three years, ask what needs to happen during that period.
This could include taking greater responsibility for client relationships, supervising junior lawyers, managing matters independently, developing a business case for a new practice area or generating additional fee income.
A clear development plan with measurable objectives is much more useful than being told to continue working hard and wait for an opportunity.
Consider leaving if your progression has stalled
If senior positions repeatedly go to external candidates despite your experience and performance, it may be time to reconsider your future at the firm.
The same applies where management continually postpones promotion discussions, provides no meaningful explanation for unsuccessful applications or expects you to perform responsibilities above your current position without recognising that contribution.
Moving to another firm can offer a faster route to career progression. An associate who has struggled to secure promotion internally may find that another firm is willing to offer a senior associate position, legal director role or even partnership.
Importantly, changing firms can also improve earning potential. Law firms sometimes offer more attractive remuneration packages to secure experienced lateral hires than they provide to existing employees receiving internal promotions.
However, lawyers should not assume that a new firm will automatically provide a better working environment. Before accepting an offer, investigate its partnership structure, promotion criteria, financial performance, workload expectations and reasons for recruiting.
Do not leave simply because someone else was promoted
There is a difference between being overlooked unfairly and not yet being ready for the next position.
A lawyer may have excellent technical skills but lack the commercial awareness, leadership experience or client development abilities expected at the next level. In particular, partnership involves more than being a technically competent solicitor. Firms generally expect partners to contribute to the management and financial success of the practice.
If feedback identifies genuine weaknesses, use it to develop your skills. Leaving without addressing those weaknesses may simply result in encountering the same barriers at another firm.
Equally, do not allow the possibility of future promotion to keep you in a position where there is little evidence of genuine career development.
How to make yourself more attractive to other law firms
Whether you decide to stay or leave, it is worth developing the qualities that make you attractive to prospective employers.
First, build a strong professional reputation in your practice area. Technical expertise, experience handling complex matters and a record of successful work can distinguish you from other candidates.
Second, develop commercial awareness. Understand how your clients make money, the pressures facing their industries and how your legal advice contributes to their business objectives.
Third, build relationships with clients and other professionals. Networking, referrals and business development become increasingly important as lawyers progress towards senior positions and partnership.
Finally, keep your CV updated and maintain an awareness of opportunities elsewhere. You do not need to be actively looking for another job to understand your market value. Knowing what other firms are offering can help you assess whether your current employer is providing competitive opportunities.