Updated by
Founded in 2019, UOLLB is a global legal education platform providing high-quality study resources, exam preparation materials and careers advice for law students. We make complex legal concepts simple and clear, helping you build knowledge, develop confidence and achieve your academic goals.
The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council has unanimously ruled that Trinidad and Tobago's laws criminalising consensual same-sex relations between adults are unconstitutional, bringing an end to a nearly decade-long legal battle over LGBTQ+ rights in the Caribbean nation.
In a judgment delivered on 10 November 2026, the five-member panel allowed an appeal brought by LGBTQ+ rights activist Jason Jones, who challenged provisions of the country's Sexual Offences Act 1986. The ruling overturns legislation that criminalised certain sexual activities between men and marks a significant development in constitutional and human rights law across the Caribbean.
The case concerned Sections 13 and 16 of the Sexual Offences Act 1986. Section 13 criminalised buggery, while Section 16 prohibited serious indecency between people of the same sex. The provisions carried potential prison sentences, including a maximum penalty of five years for certain offences.
Jones first brought his legal challenge in 2017, arguing that the legislation violated fundamental rights protected by the Constitution of Trinidad and Tobago. In April 2018, the country's High Court ruled in his favour, finding that the provisions were unconstitutional.
However, the government appealed the decision. In March 2025, the Court of Appeal overturned the High Court's ruling by a majority of two to one, effectively restoring the criminalisation of consensual same-sex relations. Jones subsequently appealed to the Privy Council, Trinidad and Tobago's final court of appeal.
The central constitutional issue concerned whether the challenged provisions were protected by Section 6 of the Constitution, which preserves certain laws that existed before the Constitution came into force in 1976. This protection, commonly referred to as a constitutional savings clause, restricts the ability of courts to invalidate certain pre-independence legislation on constitutional grounds.
The government argued that the provisions were protected by this constitutional safeguard. However, the Privy Council rejected that position, finding that Sections 13 and 16 of the 1986 Act constituted new legislation introduced after the Constitution came into force. They therefore could not benefit from the protection afforded to existing laws under Section 6.
The court also rejected the argument that criminalising consensual same-sex relations could be justified by tradition. It found that the government had failed to provide sufficient evidence to establish that the restrictions were reasonably justifiable in a society that respects individual rights and freedoms.
Delivering the judgment, Lord Sales explained that the fundamental right to respect for private and family life protects sexual orientation as a core aspect of personal identity. Criminalising private and consensual intimate relationships between adults of the same sex could not be justified.
The ruling represents a significant victory for Jones and LGBTQ+ rights organisations, which have argued that laws criminalising same-sex relationships contribute to discrimination, social stigma and the marginalisation of LGBTQ+ communities, even where prosecutions are rare.
Jones welcomed the decision but emphasised that the judgment does not resolve the wider human rights and equality challenges facing LGBTQ+ people in Trinidad and Tobago. The country's Attorney General, whose office opposed the appeal, had not immediately commented following the ruling.
The decision also has wider implications for other Caribbean countries that retain legislation criminalising same-sex relations. Several countries in the region, including Grenada, Jamaica and St Vincent and the Grenadines, continue to have laws restricting consensual same-sex intimacy. The Privy Council's reasoning may provide important legal guidance for future constitutional challenges to similar legislation.
Although the ruling is a major development in the protection of individual rights, it does not by itself eliminate all forms of discrimination against LGBTQ+ people. Its immediate significance is that consensual same-sex relations between adults can no longer be criminalised under the challenged provisions in Trinidad and Tobago.
The case demonstrates the continuing importance of constitutional safeguards, judicial independence and human rights protections in challenging discriminatory legislation, particularly laws inherited from the colonial period.