Updated by
Founded in 2019, UOLLB is a global legal education platform providing high-quality study resources, exam preparation materials and careers advice for law students. We make complex legal concepts simple and clear, helping you build knowledge, develop confidence and achieve your academic goals.
A magistrate has received a formal warning for misconduct after repeatedly making comments about the integrity, professionalism and competence of officials at HM Courts and Tribunals Service (HMCTS), with investigators concluding that his conduct went beyond reasonable criticism.
Michael Dunstan JP was sanctioned following a complaint concerning his written and verbal communications with the HMCTS Magistrates’ Expenses Team. The complaint alleged that Dunstan had questioned the integrity, impartiality, professionalism and competence of HMCTS officials while suggesting that he had been victimised in connection with decisions concerning his expenses claims.
According to the Judicial Conduct Investigations Office, Dunstan repeatedly challenged the integrity, professionalism and judgement of an HMCTS official, despite receiving assurances that his allegations were unfounded. His communications were considered to have bordered on harassment.
Dunstan denied engaging in inappropriate conduct or discriminatory behaviour, maintaining that his comments were based on genuine concerns arising from decisions about his expenses claims. However, he acknowledged that one particular issue was not attributable to the HMCTS official concerned and apologised.
An investigation conducted under the Judicial Conduct (Magistrates) Rules 2023 concluded that, although Dunstan was entitled to raise concerns about the handling of his expenses, the manner in which he communicated them was unacceptable.
The nominated committee member of the North-West Conduct Advisory Committee found that his comments went beyond reasonable criticism and failed to treat the HMCTS official with fairness, respect and professionalism.
The investigation concluded that the conduct did not amount to harassment but was sufficiently serious to constitute misconduct.
In deciding the appropriate sanction, the committee considered Dunstan's previously unblemished conduct record spanning more than 23 years. Despite his lengthy record without previous disciplinary concerns, the seriousness of his communications warranted formal action.
Mr Justice Keehan, acting on behalf of the Lady Chief Justice and with the agreement of the Lord Chancellor, subsequently issued Dunstan with a formal warning.
The JCIO emphasised that judicial office holders are expected to maintain high standards of conduct in their dealings with others, including those working within the court administration system. The Guide to Judicial Conduct requires magistrates and other judicial office holders to treat people fairly and respectfully while acting professionally and courteously.
The accompanying Statement of Expected Behaviour also reminds judicial office holders to consider how their words and behaviour may affect others.
The case highlights the distinction between a judicial office holder's right to raise legitimate concerns and the professional standards expected when challenging decisions made by court officials. While magistrates are entitled to question administrative decisions and pursue complaints, such communications must remain fair, respectful and professional.
Under the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, disciplinary sanctions available for judicial misconduct include formal advice, formal warnings, reprimands and removal from office, reflecting different levels of seriousness.
The decision serves as a reminder that judicial office holders are subject to conduct expectations extending beyond their work in courtrooms. Their dealings with administrative staff and other individuals must also reflect the standards of courtesy, fairness and professionalism expected of those holding judicial office.