Updated by
Founded in 2019, UOLLB is a global legal education platform providing high-quality study resources, exam preparation materials and careers advice for law students. We make complex legal concepts simple and clear, helping you build knowledge, develop confidence and achieve your academic goals.
Barristers could face disciplinary action, including being barred from practising, if they perpetuate rape myths in court, the Justice Secretary has warned, following widespread criticism of defence tactics used during Russell Brand’s rape trial.
Alex Norris, the Labour MP who serves as Justice Secretary and Lord Chancellor, has written to the Bar Standards Board, which regulates barristers in England and Wales, calling for stronger professional standards to prevent lawyers from relying on misconceptions about sexual violence when defending clients accused of rape and sexual offences.
Norris said the regulator must send a clear message to the profession about the harm caused by such arguments, adding that the perpetuation of rape myths in courtrooms was unacceptable.
In his letter, he said: “The board must send a strong signal to the profession on the harm arising from rape myths, and that the perpetuation of such myths within a court room is unacceptable, just as they are unacceptable in our society at large.”
What are rape myths?
Rape myths are false beliefs and stereotypes about rape, sexual assault and how victims are expected to behave. They can influence how complainants are perceived and undermine the credibility of their accounts.
Examples include assumptions that a genuine rape victim would always physically resist, scream or immediately report an assault to the police. Other misconceptions include believing that a person's clothing, alcohol consumption or relationship with the accused somehow implies consent.
These assumptions are misleading because consent must be freely given. A person's failure to physically resist or immediately report an incident does not mean that sexual activity was consensual.
The Government's intervention aims to ensure that such misconceptions are not used to influence juries or undermine complainants during criminal proceedings.
Russell Brand trial sparks scrutiny
The intervention follows controversy surrounding the cross-examination and closing arguments delivered by Russell Brand’s barrister, Ian Winter KC, during the comedian’s trial at Southwark Crown Court.
Brand was convicted of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault involving four women. He was subsequently sentenced to 10 and a half years in prison.
During his closing speech, Winter questioned why Brand’s accusers had not resisted, screamed or attempted to leave during the alleged attacks. He also challenged the jury to consider whether Brand could have committed the offences given the number of women he had sexual relationships with over the years.
The arguments prompted criticism from campaigners, who said they relied on outdated assumptions about how victims of sexual violence should behave.
Norris's intervention puts the spotlight on the professional responsibilities of barristers when challenging complainants' evidence in sexual offence cases, and whether existing regulatory standards provide sufficient protection against the use of prejudicial arguments.
BSB considers tougher professional standards
The Bar Standards Board said it agreed that rape and sexual assault cases must be decided on evidence rather than prejudice.
A spokesperson said the regulator had established an expert reference group to advise on strengthening professional standards for barristers working in rape and serious sexual offence cases.
The BSB added that it would continue working urgently with the Government to address the concerns raised.
The possibility of further disciplinary consequences could represent a significant development for the profession, although the regulator's independence remains an important consideration.
The Bar Council, which represents barristers in England and Wales, acknowledged the concerns but stressed that defendants must retain the right to have evidence tested in court.
A spokesperson said defendants denying rape allegations were entitled to challenge the prosecution's case and that the burden remained on the prosecution to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
The organisation also highlighted the importance of maintaining the BSB's independence from government intervention.
Debate over rape myths and judicial independence
The Government's intervention has also reignited debate about the role of judges in addressing rape myths during trials.
Ministers are considering whether judges should be required to give juries specific directions explaining common misconceptions about rape and sexual assault.
However, Lady Chief Justice Baroness Carr has cautioned against legislative intervention that could undermine judicial independence. She has argued that rape trials are fact-specific and that judges must retain discretion over the directions given to juries.
The debate comes amid wider efforts to improve the treatment of victims within the criminal justice system and encourage more survivors to report sexual violence.
The judge who sentenced Brand, Mr Justice Bennathan, was previously praised by the Criminal Bar Association and campaign groups for his remarks challenging misconceptions about rape.
During sentencing, he emphasised that a woman's clothing, location or alcohol consumption did not remove her right to refuse sexual activity or seek justice when that right was violated.
The case has intensified scrutiny of how complainants are treated in court and the balance between robust defence advocacy and the need to prevent arguments based on prejudice.
Norris's letter signals the Government's determination to push for stronger protections, leaving the BSB to consider how professional standards should evolve while preserving defendants' right to a fair trial.